7 Steps to Take When a Home Inspection Finds Major Issues

by Editorial Team

Last Updated: November 16, 2026

Quick Summary

When a home inspection finds major issues, you have options and none of them require panicking, because the report is information, not a verdict. Read the full report, sort findings by severity and cost, and get contractor estimates on big-ticket items before you respond to the seller.

  • Group findings into safety issues, big-ticket systems, and routine maintenance, with safety first.
  • Get written contractor estimates on the roof, foundation, plumbing, electrical, and HVAC.
  • Reasonable requests focus on safety and major systems, not a punch list of small fixes.
  • Send your repair request through your agent so it stays part of the written record.
  • Verify seller repairs with receipts, permits, and a reinspection before closing.
Facing a rough inspection report?Sierra Player Real Estate helps buyers negotiate repairs and protect their deposit.
Get Home Report

Table of Contents

What to Do When a Home Inspection Comes Back With Issues

A home inspection report rarely comes back clean. According to Opendoor's guide to what home inspectors look for, most inspections turn up at least one issue, and many reports run dozens of pages. So what happens if home inspection finds major issues? The short answer: you have options, and none of them require panicking.

The report is information, not a verdict.

Couple and real estate agent reviewing a home inspection report process flowchart at a kitchen table
Couple and real estate agent reviewing a home inspection report process flowchart at a kitchen table

Here is the process, step by step.

Step 1: Read the Full Report Before You React

Read every page before you call anyone. Reports mix serious findings with minor notes, and the summary page can make small items sound alarming. Take notes on what is flagged and where.

Step 2: Sort Findings by Severity and Cost

Group items into three buckets: safety issues, big-ticket systems, and routine maintenance. Safety issues come first. Cosmetic wear can wait.

Step 3: Get Contractor Estimates on the Big-Ticket Items

Bring in licensed contractors for the roof, foundation, plumbing, electrical, and HVAC. Written estimates turn vague worry into real numbers you can negotiate with.

Major Defects vs. Routine Maintenance: A Buyer's Decision Framework

A major defect is a problem that affects safety, structural integrity, or a major system, or one that carries a high repair cost relative to the price of the home. Routine maintenance is normal wear a homeowner should expect to handle. The hard part is not defining the terms, it is sorting a 40-page report into those buckets without treating every line item as equally urgent.

A simple three-question triage can help buyers sort most findings:

  1. Is anyone unsafe right now? Active gas leaks, exposed wiring, missing handrails on a raised deck, a failed water heater flue, or a roof with active leaks all move to the top regardless of cost. These are the items a lender or insurer may also care about.
  2. Does it threaten the structure or a major system? Foundation movement, rotted framing, a failing sewer line, an undersized or recalled electrical panel, and a roof at the end of its service life are big-ticket items. Get a licensed contractor or, for structural concerns, a structural engineer before you decide anything.
  3. Is it normal wear? Worn caulk, a sticky interior door, a loose cabinet hinge, missing outlet covers, or a dripping faucet are maintenance. Note them, but do not build a negotiation around them.

A useful rule of thumb: anything a licensed trade would need to open a wall, pull a permit, or make safe is worth pricing before you respond to the seller. Cosmetic items and small safety fixes can usually be handled with a simple repair request or absorbed after closing.

Finding Typical Category Buyer Action
Roof near end of life Major defect Get estimate, request credit or repair
Foundation cracks with movement Major defect Structural engineer evaluation first
Active water leak or mold Major defect Request repair and reinspection
Older electrical panel Major or safety Licensed electrician estimate
Failed sewer line Major defect Camera inspection and repair bid
Worn caulk, sticky doors Routine maintenance Note it, proceed
Missing outlet covers Minor safety Ask for a simple fix

Watch out: inspectors report what they can see, not what a repair will cost. A finding labeled "monitor" can still turn into a significant repair once a specialist opens the wall, so get bids on anything structural or system-related before your contingency deadline, not after.

The National Association of Realtors' guidance on common inspection issues notes that inspectors may flag potential safety concerns even when they are relatively minor. That is why the triage above separates safety from cost: a missing outlet cover and a failed electrical panel are both "safety," but only one should change your decision.

Making Reasonable Requests After a Home Inspection

Reasonable requests after a home inspection focus on safety and major systems, not a punch list of small fixes. Sellers are not automatically required to make every repair. As Zillow explains on mandatory repairs after inspection points out, no repair is legally mandatory in most cases; the outcome depends on your contract.

Ask for licensed repairs on active leaks, safety hazards, and failing systems. Skip cosmetic items. Buyers preparing their asks can review negotiation tips for buyers, and if you are weighing a credit instead, see whether a buyer can ask for closing costs.

How to Write a Home Inspection Repair Request Letter

A home inspection repair request letter is a written document that lists the specific items you want the seller to fix or credit, with contractor estimates attached. Keep it short and factual.

  • Reference the inspection date and contingency deadline
  • List each item with the inspector's wording
  • Attach contractor estimates for big-ticket items
  • State whether you want a repair or a credit
  • Set a response date inside your contingency period

Send it through your agent so the request stays part of the written record.

When to Walk Away After a Home Inspection

Walking away makes sense when the cost or risk is more than you can absorb. Structural problems, unresolved safety hazards, a failed major system with no realistic repair path, or a seller who refuses to address serious defects are common reasons buyers cancel.

When to walk away after a home inspection depends almost entirely on your contract, not on the report. Inspection contingencies, cancellation rights, notice requirements, and deadlines vary by state and by the specific purchase agreement you signed. There is no single national rule, so the practical move is to read your contingency clause and confirm the terms in writing with your agent before you make any decision.

A common pattern in a standard inspection contingency looks like this:

  • You have a set number of days from the inspection (or from contract acceptance) to deliver a written response.
  • Your response must be in writing and delivered the way the contract requires, usually through your agent, often with a signed notice or addendum.
  • If you cancel within the contingency period, you generally recover your earnest money, subject to the contract's notice rules.
  • If the deadline passes without a written response, you are usually treated as having accepted the property in its inspected condition, and your deposit is no longer protected by that contingency.

Watch out: a verbal "we're out" to your agent is not the same as the written notice your contract requires. Buyers who miss the notice deadline, even by a day, can forfeit the deposit even when the defect is genuinely serious.

Before you walk, price the exit. Get contractor bids on the major items so you know how large the gap is before you decide. If the numbers are close, a renegotiation may serve you better than cancellation. If you are weighing a credit instead of walking, see whether a buyer can ask for closing costs, and review negotiation tips for buyers before you send a response.

Walking away is also a financing and insurance question, not just a repair question. Certain safety or condition issues can affect lender approval, insurability, or the appraisal even when you and the seller agree on a fix. If your lender or insurer flags the property, that can change the walk-away math independently of the inspection report.

Protecting Your Earnest Money and Inspection Contingency

Your inspection contingency is a contract term that lets you cancel or renegotiate based on findings within a set period. Miss the deadline and you lose that use.

Watch out: buyers who wait on contractor estimates past the contingency deadline can forfeit their deposit. Confirm the date in writing with your agent. If funds are tight, review how much down payment first-time buyers need before you commit.

Verifying Seller Repairs Before Closing

Verify repairs with receipts, permits, and a reinspection before closing. Ask for licensed contractor invoices and any required permits, then walk the property again or hire your inspector for a quick reinspection.

Be cautious with seller-performed repairs. Unpermitted work can surface later as a code problem, and unresolved issues can affect insurance and appraisal.

Get Expert Guidance on Your Nevada County Inspection

An inspection report is easier to act on with an agent who negotiates these requests every week. Sierra Player Real Estate helps buyers sort findings, request repairs, and protect their deposit through closing.

Our team offers dedicated negotiation support, personalized neighborhood matching in Grass Valley, Nevada City, and Penn Valley, and detailed video tours for out-of-area buyers. If you want a local guide, explore our agent referrals and free buyers guide.

A major inspection finding is a negotiation point, not a dead end. Sierra Player Real Estate can help you review the report, request the right repairs, and move forward with confidence. Get started with Sierra Player Real Estate and secure a home you can buy with clear eyes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is considered a major issue in a home inspection?

Major issues are defects that affect safety, structural integrity, or carry high repair costs. Common examples include foundation problems, roof failure, active water damage or leaks, mold growth, outdated electrical systems, and HVAC failures. According to Opendoor, 86% of inspections find at least one issue, but most findings are minor. The National Association of Realtors notes that inspectors may flag safety concerns even when relatively minor, so buyers should separate serious defects from routine maintenance before reacting.

Can I negotiate a price reduction after a home inspection?

Yes, you can often negotiate a price reduction, seller credit, or repairs after a home inspection, depending on your purchase agreement and inspection contingency. Zillow notes that no repairs are legally mandatory after an inspection, so sellers may agree, counter, or decline. Your leverage depends on the severity of findings, current market conditions, and how your contract is written. Document each issue with contractor estimates and submit reasonable requests before your contingency deadline.

What happens to my earnest money if I walk away after a home inspection?

Your earnest money is generally refundable if you cancel within your inspection contingency period and follow the contract's notice requirements. If you walk away after the contingency expires, or for reasons not covered by the contract, you may forfeit the deposit. Rules vary by state and by contract terms, so review your purchase agreement carefully and submit any cancellation in writing before the deadline to protect your deposit.

What are reasonable requests after a home inspection?

Reasonable requests focus on safety hazards, significant defects, and items that affect financing or insurance, such as active leaks, roof damage, or electrical problems. Requesting a seller credit for a documented repair estimate is often cleaner than asking the seller to perform repairs themselves, since seller-performed work can be rushed or unpermitted. Avoid asking for cosmetic updates or routine maintenance, which can weaken your negotiating position and strain the deal.

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name

Name

Phone*

Phone

Message

Message
Sierra Player

+1(530) 604-9319

sierraplayerrealtor@gmail.com